PersonalizeThe Washington PostCampaign 2012CongressCourts &LawThe Fed PageHealth CarePollingWhite HouseBlogs & ColumnsIssues: EnergyIn the NewsRon Paul Debate winners and losers Jan Brewer Florida poll Aneesh Chopra ???initialComments:true! pubdate:01/27/2012 13:28 EST! commentPeriod:14! commentEndDate:2/10/12 1:28 EST! currentDate:1/27/12 1:0 EST! allowComments:true! displayComments:true!
Photos: GOP candidates at Florida debate
What readers think they really said
Crazy things they confiscate at customs
Extravagant D.C. homesTwo GOP revolutions, two different outcomes
View Photo Gallery — ?A look at the former House speaker now seeking the GOP presidential nomination.
Text SizePrintE-mailReprints By David A. Fahrenthold and and Paul Kane, The first Republican revolution had a short, sharp battle plan: the “Contract with America.” Ten big ideas. Three pages of text.
The second Republican revolution — the one now struggling for oxygen on Capitol Hill — did it differently. Its “Pledge to America” noodled on for 48 pages. It contained less ambitious ideas, but glossy photos of 42 GOP congressmen.
Loading...CommentsWeigh InCorrections?
A look at how the 2012 Republican candidates for president differ on key issues.Video
Newt Gingrich explained his idea for a lunar colony, while Mitt Romney attacked him for promising each state what they wanted. (Jan. 26)In 1995, that first GOP-led House passed 302 bills in its first year, laying out plans to reform welfare, presidential veto power and criminal sentencing. The current House passed less than 200 bills. Its best-known achievement was an agreement to keep paying the national debt.
On the presidential campaign trail, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich (Ga.) is being roasted for the way he led that first Republican surge. Former colleagues have said Gingrich became a meddling bully, constantly distracted by his own brainstorms.
But on Capitol Hill, his revolution is looking more remarkable in hindsight.
That’s because the current GOP leadership — trying to prove that it could succeed without Gingrich’s top-down, micromanaged style — could wind up proving the opposite instead.
The reward for their loose, anti-Gingrich management style has been embarrassing rebellions by the rank-and-file and a dearth of real-world accomplishments. This has been the bitter lesson: Running a revolution is hard.
And Gingrich, for all his flaws, somehow made it work for a while.
“We got the agenda. He was a good leader for that time,” said former Rep. George Nethercutt (R-Wash.), who served from 1995 to 2005. “When we started losing elections — you know, after the [government shutdown] — that’s when the confidence level dropped on Newt Gingrich.”
This week, the campaign of former Massachusetts governor Mitt Romney — Gingrich’s chief rival for the GOP nomination — has served up Republican legislators to blast Gingrich’s time as speaker.
“He could not get elected Speaker of the House right now,” Rep. Jason Chaffetz (Utah), a Romney supporter, said Thursday. Chaffetz took office in 2009, 10 years after Gingrich left Congress under pressure from unhappy conservatives. “He is an unreliable leader who was pushed out the door.”
The job is different now: Current speaker, John A. Boehner (R-Ohio), faces an array of problems that Gingrich did not.
Gingrich had shaped the campaign that took the House: New members felt they owed their jobs to him. With Boehner, it was the other way around — the rowdy, anti-establishment Tea Party movement helped elect the members who put him in charge in 2011. Now, some members have calculated it is less risky to defy the speaker than to defy backers at home.
Also, Gingrich faced a sometimes-resistant Republican Senate, but Boehner must deal with a far less cooperative Democratic one. And Republicans say President Obama is far less open to dealmaking than President Bill Clinton was in Gingrich’s time.
“There is not a willing partner here, and that’s a story we’re going to have to tell,” House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-Va.) said this week. “We’ve begun to change, we need willing partners to help us continue on that change.”
Continued12Next PageEmailTumblrRedditStumbleuponDiggDeliciousWeigh InDiscussion PolicyAbout Discussions, Badges Newest firstOldest firstMost Recommended first SuperFan BadgeSuperFan badge holders consistently post smart, timely comments about Washington area sports and teams.
More about badges | Request a badge Culture Connoisseur BadgeCulture Connoisseurs consistently offer thought-provoking, timely comments on the arts, lifestyle and entertainment.
More about badges | Request a badge Fact Checker BadgeFact Checkers contribute questions, information and facts to The Fact Checker.
More about badges | Request a badge Washingtologist BadgeWashingtologists consistently post thought-provoking, timely comments on events, communities, and trends in the Washington area.
More about badges | Request a badge Post Writer BadgeThis commenter is a Washington Post editor, reporter or producer.
Post Forum BadgePost Forum members consistently offer thought-provoking, timely comments on politics, national and international affairs.
More about badges | Request a badge Weather Watcher BadgeWeather Watchers consistently offer thought-provoking, timely comments on climates and forecasts.
More about badges | Request a badge World Watcher BadgeWorld Watchers consistently offer thought-provoking, timely comments on international affairs.
More about badges | Request a badge Post RecommendedWashington Post reporters or editors recommend this comment or reader post.
You must be logged in to report a comment.
Sign in hereYou must be logged in to recommend a comment.
Sign in hereComments our editors find particularly useful or relevant are displayed in Top Comments, as are comments by users with these badges: . Replies to those posts appear here, as well as posts by staff writers.
All comments are posted in the All Comments tab.
More about badgesGet a badgeTo pause and restart automatic updates, click "Live" or "Paused". If paused, you'll be notified of the number of additional comments that have come in.
Comments our editors find particularly useful or relevant are displayed in Top Comments, as are comments by users with these badges: . Replies to those posts appear here, as well as posts by staff writers. + SHARE THIS DEBATE
Featured Blogs & Columns
Election 2012News and conversation about the 2012 elections.
Fact CheckerThe truth behind the rhetoric
The TakeDan Balz on politics WP Social Reader Hide this Friends' Activity Most Popular in politics Most Popular in politics Most Popular Right Now
Your Friends’ Most Recent Activity
View More ActivityPowered by
The Post Most: PoliticsMost-viewed stories, videos and galleries int he past two hoursMost PopularCNN Florida debate: Winners and losersRon Paul signed off on racist 1990s newsletters, associates sayFlorida GOP debate: Gingrich and Romney clash on immigration, taxesObama-backed electric car battery company files for bankruptcy protectionFact checking the CNN debate in JacksonvilleTop VideosBest GOP debate lines, from grandmas to lunar colonies (1:36)Jan Brewer defends pointing finger at Obama (1:46)Ron Paul challenges candidates to bike ride (1:18)Ariz. Governor Jan Brewer squares off with ObamaStephen Colbert: New attack ad targeting RomneyTop GalleriesPresident Obama on the campaign trailCandidates debate in JacksonvilleNewt Gingrich's 2012 runState of the UnionCampaign 2012: Ron Paul Fact or Fiction? Loading... Track all the Campaign 2012 fact checks Campaign 2012 tools 
Republican primary tracker Explore the state of the 2012 race in key early states.
Mad Money: Campaign ads Watch the latest campaign ads and track how much candidates spend.
Campaign Finance Explorer See who's raising and spending the most money.
2012 Presidential Candidates
Mitt Romney
Newt Gingrich
Ron Paul
Rick Santorum
Barack ObamaSee AllFeatured Advertiser LinksMesothelioma cancer shatters lives. Find out what to do before the killer strikes the one you love.>>Actos gave you bladder cancer? You may be entitled to compensation. Learn how to file an Actos lawsuit.>>Help Barack stand up for working Americans. Join our campaign now.>>The only candidate fighting for the middle class: Pres. Obama. Join us.>>Sign up for email updates from President Obama's 2012 campaign.>>Sign up for official email updates from Barack Obama's campaign.>>Looking to buy a home? Visit TWP Real Estate section for the latest open houses.>>Make Your Vanguard Investing More Profitable - Free Research Report Reveals Best & Worst Funds>>Top politics Stories People Also ReadMost Popular VideosCNN Florida debate: Winners and losersAaron Blake; Rachel Weiner 
Ron Paul signed off on racist newsletters in the 1990s, associates sayJerry Markon; Alice Crites 
Florida GOP debate: Gingrich and Romney clash on immigration, taxes::unspecified:: 
Obama-backed car battery company files for bankruptcy protectionCarol D. Leonnig 
Fact checking the CNN debate in JacksonvilleGlenn Kessler 
State of the Union 2012: Obama speech transcript::unspecified:: 
Mitt Romney’s tax return problemAl Kamen 
The defense budget and civilian federal payEd O'keefe 
Obama tangles with Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer over immigration bookDavid Nakamura Mitt Romney back in the lead in FloridaAaron Blake 
A bogus chart on Obama and the debt gets a new lease on lifeGlenn Kessler 
Newt Gingrich launches furious attacks against Mitt Romney in Florida speechAmy Gardner; Rosalind S. Helderman 
Romney boosted in Florida by new poll numbers, strong debate performanceDan Balz; Amy Gardner 
Poll watcher: Romney leads Gingrich in FloridaScott Clement Romney campaign to correct financial disclosure forms to include overseas incomeDan Eggen 
Obama argues GOP this fall will have to explain economic strategies that caused near-meltdownAssociated Press 
Survey paints portrait of black women in AmericaKrissah Thompson Federal retirees face confusion, possibly payment delayJoe Davidson Fact-checking the 2012 State of the Union speechGlenn Kessler 
Obama proposes plan to reduce college costsDavid Nakamura Ways you can get us Mobile Apps Newsletter & alerts RSS Post Store Facebook Photo Store Twitter Washington Post Live The Washington Post Work for us Community Relations PostPoints Corrections/Suggestions Archive Contact the Ombudsman Report a problem Web site Make us your homepage Digital Guidelines Ask The Post Newspaper Subscribe Home delivery service e-Replica Advertise In the newspaper On the web site Mobile Events The Washington Post Company Post Company web sites Partners Slate Express Night Out Captial Business El Tiempo Latino The Root Foreign Policy Trove Post Tickets Capitol Deal Service Alley Post Master Class WP Live Student Advisor College Reviews © 1996- The Washington Post Terms of Service Privacy Policy Reprints and Permissions Help Contact Us Ad Choices 